Book Jacket

 

rank 970
word count 84376
date submitted 16.07.2009
date updated 16.08.2009
genres: Fiction, Science Fiction, Fantasy, ...
classification: moderate
complete

The monodreme

I Moore

A teenage girl becomes as powerful as God. Will she hold onto her sanity?

 

What would happen if you could make anything happen?


When Sal is faced with this question she creates a replica of herself to take her place while she runs off to hide and try and figure out what to do.


We follow the adventures and misadventures of her three friends and her replica as they try to find her before she goes insane. But they’re just ordinary kids, playing with toys created by an inexperienced god. They’re on a collision course with the price of power, the price of power given for free.


What would you do if you could do anything? What would you really do?


Would you be a good person?


What would a teenage girl do?


Is there any question more terrifying?


NOTE: If you enjoy the opening to the story, and would like to know what Sal finally decides to do with her tremendous power, take a look at Chapter 15. There'll be stuff you don't quite get, of course, but it's a momentous chapter and I'm aching for feedback on it. Thanks

 
rate the book

to rate this book please Register or Login

 

tags

adventure, exciting, fantastical, metaphysical, mind expanding, philosophical, profound, thought provoking

on 30 watchlists

145 comments

 

Text Size

Text Colour

Chapters

1

report abuse

The End of the World

We ran for our lives.

It was Pee’s fault.

At first we were frozen, crouched there in the dark, barely able to breathe, staring at something that had changed our world in an instant from one that we knew, and understood, into…something else.  We just stared.

But then he whimpered and ran, snapping our paralysis like a rib, and we jumped up and chased after him.  Fear clogged my throat, oozed out of my pores, pounded in my brain.  A mindless panic expanded inside me like an airbag, pushing my personality out. I wasn’t myself anymore, just a running thing.

And all the while I was dimly aware of a small part of myself, a silent observer that was actually excited.  But my mind was a muffled voice now, sent out of the room for its own good.  Survival was everything.  Luxuries such as thinking could come later – if there was a later.

I was in third place, behind Pee and Osmo.  I stumbled endlessly over the uneven ground because I couldn’t see a thing, but once we got past the perimeter fence, and in amongst the warehouses, I started to make good speed.  I was about to overtake Pee, who had slipped into second place behind Osmo, when my inbuilt chivalry started to kick in, just as automatic as my running.  I couldn’t leave any of them behind, especially someone as little and helpless as Pee.  It’s not that I’m brave or something.  I know I’m not.  It’s just that my body decides things for me sometimes.  So I slowed down, expecting Sal to catch up and overtake at any moment, because she was easily faster than Pee.  Then if anyone were going to fall victim to what was behind us it would be me.

But Sal didn’t catch up.

We were all the way to the hole in the wall that leads back onto Brookland Common by the time I realised.  I had to shout to the other two to stop.  Otherwise they would have run all the way home without looking over their shoulders once.  Our throats were dry and tight from breathing the cold air so hard.  The streetlights on the far side of the wall coated us in an unhealthy yellow brown light.

“Sal’s still back there.”  My voice sounded like somebody else’s, so serious.

Beneath my coat my back was hot and clammy, while above the neckline my ears glowed with the cold.  Osmo swore.  Bits of gravel and broken glass crunched beneath our feet as we started back the way we had come.

We didn’t speak at first.  There was no question of us carrying on without Sal.  So we jogged wordlessly back in amongst the warehouses and commercial units.  Osmo and Pee were looking wide-eyed and haunted.

“Is it me or are we dreaming this?” I muttered eventually.  Osmo nodded.  Pee had a fixed frown on his face, as if he was sitting an exam, or as if he were constipated or something.  He kept making this mewling sound from way back in his throat.  I don’t think he realised he was doing it.

“What are we going to do?  I don’t know what we think we’re going to do!”

“Shut up, Pee.  I’m scared enough as it is.”

“Just don’t think,” said Osmo.  “Just shut up and don’t think and keep on going.”

It was the only sensible idea.

When we got back to the fence I crouched down and took the lead, still playing the protector.  I kept low behind the overgrown weeds and bits of wall, working my way forward.  Every now and then a glimpse of the golden light caught me, and I reeled in disbelief that we hadn’t imagined it, some kind of group hallucination.  But I still wasn’t convinced that I wasn’t dreaming.

We could leave her, I thought to myself, cringing at my own cowardice but following the thought anyway.  Maybe it was too late to help her.  Maybe it would be more use to go and get help.  But my body decided to keep going forward.

We finally got as close to where we’d left Sal as we were going to get without giving ourselves away.  I inched my head over the edge of some crumbled old brickwork, trying to keep my face in the shadow of a spindly old bush that was leaning over from the other side.  When I saw what I saw my chest started to shudder, and I couldn’t stop it for the life of me.

My god, it was real.

 

 

Sal liked science fiction and I think that had a lot to do with why she hadn’t followed us.  I don’t know how many girls are into science fiction compared to boys, maybe more than you’d think, but Sal loved it.  I know she believed in life on other planets because she’d told me.  As far as she was concerned it was simply a question of when the human race would be mature enough to receive our visitation from the stars.  That’s if the aliens weren’t already here: learning about us, guiding us, helping us to evolve.  It seemed plausible to both of us.

But where we disagreed, me and Sal, was the bit about how ready we humans were for first contact.  I thought it should be any day now – well, I felt ready, personally, being an evolved, well-balanced individual.  And though Sal seemed to agree that I wasn’t the most stupid example of the human species she’d ever met she didn’t have that much faith in the rest.  As far as she was concerned it would probably be another thousand years before humanity got over itself finally and grew up.

“Human development,” she said, “if you average it out around the globe, is about equivalent to that of a teenager.  Or in other words: we’re pretty messed up.”

I liked Sal.  Well, that might be a bit of an understatement.  Actually, saying ‘that might be a bit of an understatement’ might be a bit of an understatement.  She was a deep thinker, a fast runner and she liked Star Trek.  And yes, she was cute.  So cute, in fact, that she could have got away with having a horrible personality, if that had been her bag.  And, let’s face it, most cute girls try that on for size, for a while at least.  She was way too cute to hang around with me.  But somehow, through some weird space-time anomaly, she’d inherited the geek gene.  She was talking about learning how to speak Klingon so she’d be able to swear at Mr. Michaels without him realising.  I didn’t think it would work.  Ask somebody if they want a nice cup of tea in Klingon and they’ll think you’re swearing at them.

But yeah, out of the four of us, she was definitely the most likely to ignore popular opinion.  Even if it meant hanging around on her own to face something potentially dangerous.  Even if her three friends were in the process of running for their teeny little lives.

I peered over the top of the wall from the safety of my shadows and I saw Sal kneeling in front of the thing that was glowing with that golden light, the thing that had floated down from the sky.

“Do you think it’s taken over her mind?” whispered Osmo.

 

 

I was George.  Back then I was what some people would call ‘precocious’, at least in some areas of my development, meaning my head.  For a fourteen year old I could knock out a pretty deep short story, the kind that made my English teacher, Miss Schneider, think the sun shone out of my notebook.  These days, because of what happened to me, I’m not the old George anymore, precocious or otherwise.  There are moments, like right now, as I write these words, I don’t even feel human.  But I shouldn’t get ahead of myself.

It was back in the olden days – not just a different century but a whole different millennium – back when we still watched Friends, back when my 10-gigabyte hard drive still seemed pretty impressive.  I lived at Number Nine, Iron Street, Banford.  I went to Penrose High School.  I hung around with Sal and Osmo and Pee.  On Saturdays we’d go ice-skating at the rink in Kurtsholme and then wander around the market, eating butter pies and trying to avoid anyone from school.  The dockland waste ground at Five Elms marked the northernmost point of our wanderground.  To the south we wouldn’t normally go further than the woods at Hensley Edge, although now and again, just to shake things up, one of our random end-of-the-line bus journeys would take us further.  And occasionally we’d take the train to Blackport, of course.  Never dull.

By evening we’d be piling heavy-eyed into my house, or Osmo’s or Sal’s – not Pee’s – for our tea.  We’d doss around indoors for a while, but sooner or later a morbid compulsion would draw us back outside to see who was out and about that was worth avoiding.  Banford was a buzzing place.  There was always something, at least on a Saturday, anyway.  I’m not saying it was always something nice, but there was always something.

Sundays, on the other hand, tend to be deadly boring wherever you are.  Well, you canna change the laws of physics can you?  On Sunday we would zombie-walk from one morose limbo moment to the next.  Well, that’s how I remember it.  This particular Sunday was the most boring ever - Granddaddy Sunday - right up `til 7:40pm, when we saw the light in the sky from Openshaw New Road and we set off chasing it.  It’s funny how the most overwhelming events in life always seem to be preceded by quiet moments.

We followed the light from the far side of the cemetery.  It drifted slowly enough for us to keep sight of it as we ran down the main path that splits the cemetery in half.  We were scared we’d lose it as it fell behind the trees near the perimeter, and there was a lot of cursing and scuffling as we fought with each other to be the first to get through the gap in the fence.  But as we emerged from the trees we saw that its descent had slowed.  It hung in the air, seeming lost, seeming to wait for us.  In the end the timing was perfect.  By the time we crossed Brookland Common and passed through the old industrial estate, and were pulling up behind the protective cover of the bit of wall on the waste ground near the docks, we were just in time to see it land barely ten metres in front of us.

It drifted down from the sky like the first star leaf of some great universal autumn.  We could see what it was now, in the centre of all that shining: an inhuman figure, clutching a smooth golden ball.

It was impossible to tell whether it was the ball that was shining or the figure or both.  We watched from the shadows.  It floated gracefully down, but when its feet touched the ground it tipped backwards drunkenly, falling against the low remnant of another wall.  The brickwork crumpled beneath its weight.  All was still for a moment.  The figure didn’t move.  Maybe it was dead.  We held our collective breath, despite all of the running we had just done.  Then it looked directly at us.

It’s funny that we had run all that way there, and then, at a panicked squeak from Pee, we turned around and started to run back again.

All of us except Sal, of course.

 

 

From the safety of my shadows I could see Sal kneeling on the floor, looking into its face.

“Do you think it’s taken over her mind?” whispered Osmo.

They were both completely still, just looking at each other, and this did seem scary to me – as scary as if it were chasing after her with a ray gun.  I couldn’t even summon the courage to answer the question, I was so afraid of being heard.

Pee put his back against the wall, slumped down onto his bum and moaned.

“We’re going to die,” he croaked.

I was dimly aware of him puking up.  Me and Osmo continued to watch the scene in front of us.  And that’s all we did.  We should have been working out some plan to rescue our friend, but we didn’t even try.  We just cowered there in the shadows and waited.  It makes me feel sick when I think about it.

What broke the spell in the end was Sal herself, standing up and turning around and walking towards us.  The light was behind her and all around her, casting her face in shadow so we couldn’t see her expression.  We had no way of telling if it was our Sal or if she’d been taken over by a telepathic nightmare from the stars.  A bit of drool at the corner of her mouth would have been enough for me.  I would have been off and running again.

“Come over,” she said as she drew near.  “He knows you’re here.  It’s alright.”

She sounded pretty normal.  As she reached the wall I was able to make out her face.  She did have something of a stunned expression, wonderstruck I’d say, but I could tell at once that it was the real her in there.

“Are you alright?” asked Osmo, and for a moment I felt bad that I hadn’t asked first, but then he said, “You’re not going to turn into a bug-eyed monster, are you?”

“I’m fine, honest.  You’ve got to come over.  It’s amazing.  You’ll regret it if you don’t.”  Sal’s voice was alive, I mean, really alive – I’d never seen her so switched on.  She was having the biggest moment of her life.

Me and Osmo looked at each other.  It was one of those looks that only happen now and again, that you share with someone who’s in the exact same extreme situation as you, when you’re both feeling the same feelings, thinking the same thoughts.  We both nodded minute little nods at the same time.  I turned to Pee who was still on the floor.

“Do you wanna stay here, Pee?”

Pee looked like a trapped animal, like a mouse that’s been caught and you can see its heart fluttering through its ribs.

“Yeah,” he managed.  “Just for a little bit.”  None of us blamed him.  I nearly got down there and joined him.  Sal smiled.

“Come out when you’re feeling a bit braver, Pee.”  Pee nodded seriously, and his eyes rolled in their sockets, scanning the darkness behind our little wall, making sure the rest of the world was still normal.  Sal turned to me and Osmo.  An excited light danced in her eyes, but her breathing was measured, her body language calm.

“It’s okay,” she said levelly.

She took the time to look each of us in the eye, to communicate her confidence.  I felt myself stand up straighter.  The small part of me that had been excited all along suddenly stepped forward, elbowing my fear to one side.  Osmo managed to raise his eyebrows high and puff out his cheeks.  He shrugged in a mock devil-may-care way and the three of us relaxed a bit, looked more like our old selves.

“Come on,” said Sal.

She beckoned with her head for us to follow her.  I’ve got to say that with the golden white light behind her, and my bloodstream pumping with adrenaline and everything, she did look beautiful in that moment.  I’m sure me and Osmo were both ready to faint on the spot - with the intensity of the situation, you know.  I feel like fainting every time I think about it.

We shuffled out from the shade of our barricade and into the beams of an alien light.

“By the way,” said Sal, “he’s telepathic.”

Chapters

1

report abuse

To leave comments on this or any book please Register or Login

subscribe to comments for this book
Efadul Huq wrote 1030 days ago

What I discovered in this piece of writing is sheer power of narration! It is only up to chapter 8 that I read so far, but that alone is enough to convince me of your mastery over your extraordinary technique of breaking the story into so many bits and strewing it all around to be gathered by the readers as if we are shell collectors on a beautiful beach.

The concept of moondrome and the way you go about it is so exciting. I agree I am a lover of fantasy and most fantasy feels good to me, but this is seriously different and deserves mention. The questions that you have raised in the long pitch are very intriguing indeed and I agree with much of what you have to say about power.

The characters are portrayed with concern and though I will need to read the entire book to make total sense of it, I loved the first 8 chapters without being able to make any ultimate sense of them, which is your success, by the way.

A great read for a rainy day! Does it remain to be said that you have my vote?

Wishes,
Efadul Huq

Elaina wrote 1031 days ago

Hi Ian

Epic imagination, indeed! This is not the kind of book to read on a screen- needs to be savoured slowly. I would have shelved this on the strength of ch1 alone, but I did read further and then moved to ch15 as requested. You are right, it is a bit confusing, one needs the weight of the other chapters to fully understand, but...brilliant, brilliant stuff. I am awed by the power, the images, the emotion. Please don't expect a crit- I feel this is way above me.

I wish this was a book in my hands.

Shelved.

Elaina
Gathering of Rain

Shona Kavi wrote 1035 days ago

I love your style - it's very professional and your prose reads so well - you've got good pace. You've got a good story- telling voice. I also think that your characters are believable. For a change, I don't think I have much criticism to give!
Shelved, Shona

Paul Bird wrote 328 days ago

I like the concept and what's more you have a nice flowing writing style that is easy to read. Nice, I would buy this for my sister. :)

Esrevinu wrote 776 days ago

Excellent storytelling
The writing is clean and flows well throughout the book
I love the short sentences and snappy dialogue
I think you made some great choices with the characters and dialogue
You will be in the top five in no time
Best wishes
Scott
The Esrevinu Chronicles/Secrets of the Elephant Rocks

Barry Wenlock wrote 788 days ago

Hi -- this is very good writing. Backed with pleasure, Barry
(Little Krisna and the Bihar Boys)

lizjrnm wrote 801 days ago

Fabulous read for young adults!! Very good pacing with a gift for imagination! BACKED

Liz
The Cheech Room

M William Anderson wrote 955 days ago

Unquestionably good writing about a question we have all wanted to ask: what would I do if I could do anything!

Shelved

andyroo wrote 978 days ago

I have had a look at your chapter fifteen, and I am perplexed, confused, astounded, shocked, overwhelmed etc etc. What a chapter! Granted there are some aspects that won't make sense to me having not read everything in between, but the feel of writing and the chaos it creates is spectacular. I love how you think with this, how you can take every day ordinary words and create an experience so other-worldly. This is like a dream, memorable yet inexplicable, and I commend you.

Andrew

alchemist wrote 981 days ago

You write really well and the story flows. I read your first chapter and the 15th as you suggested but found the 15th less punchy. I think you crammed too much explaining into it, which makes the action slower. Perhaps you can read it aloud then edit it so any words you don't need go. Of course, this is just my opinion, so you are free to take it or leave it.

Winterflood wrote 984 days ago

It is always good to start with running, plenty of action

One things that did make me stumble was when you said I was in third place but no mention of anyone else behind the character and then we get a mention of Sal not being there but Sal hasn’t been mention before. Probably just me, but that did catch me.

I presume this is talking from the future perspective, as it seems to say back then, etc. It is also a bit strange with the bold speech, but then that is what you was aiming for.

It looks like an interesting start and some good ideas in there, so good luck with the tale

ironjacket wrote 991 days ago

Great energy and atmosphere

Helen Bell wrote 992 days ago

Ian, I can't say anything new in praise that hasn't already been said, so just going to shelve it and leave it at that.
Helen (The Girl With No Shadow)

jcmcgowan wrote 992 days ago

You cast a spell from the beginning. This is an original tale with an intriguing premise and impressive depth. The narrative well set up and developed; the writing is smooth and mostly flawless. And, as others have commented, chapter 15 is quite special.....Well done!

Chris (J.C.), The Big God Network

Lorelli wrote 993 days ago

I love the urgency of your opening paragraphs - they hook you into the story and leave you gasping for breath by the end of the scene - fab!

This has great action, combined with a good depth of description and still keeps up a quick, flowing pace. I think one of the real strengths of this piece is the narrative voice, it speaks to the reader and gives the feeling that we're there, part of the story too. That's a real skill.

Shelved :-)

Best wishes
Lorelli (The Man Whisperer)

dawnswordfish wrote 995 days ago

An excellent and gripping first chapter and an exciting and disturbing premise. Backed with pleasure
Dawn (Not The Young & Perky Escort Agency)

lawdog wrote 996 days ago

Perhaps its the size of the type or the way it was organized, I had to fight the urge to skim in the first two chapters. I know it wasn't the writing. But as requested, I looked at ch 15. I didn't skim a word or even felt the urge to. A new take on the Day the Earth Stood Still. Wonderful.

I did also get a little bit of a sense of overwriting at times, nothing that a little tightening couldn't fix, and it wasn't enough to make me not want to keep going.

I really hope this takes you far, not just on this site of course but out into Barnes and Nobles, Borders, and every mom and pop bookshop. This is good stuff overall.

Shelved.

barabajagle wrote 997 days ago

fascinating take on temptation. how can one choose unless one really knows what's being sacrificed? timeless conceit in a great new wrapping.

Carrots wrote 998 days ago

The use of questions in the pitch really worked with me. I was drawn in thinking about possible answers. This is a very deep and thoughtful book. The fundamental idea is profound and far-reaching, but it is backed up with well-researched facts that give it credibility. The imagery is outstanding and I can well see it being made into a cult film. Backed.

Lisa Blue Eyes wrote 998 days ago

You are a storyteller for sure. This is excellent. Then again, you knew that already, right. :) I think this story strikes the right balance between unique storyline and characters and brilliant narrative. EVer congrats, you're shelved.

Anistasya wrote 999 days ago

Hi Ian,
Here is my swap read as promised. Sorry it took so long for me to get here.
This book is an easy read to begin with, and when I jumped to chapter fifteen I thought 'wow, this is epic!'
My only suggestion would be that you might consider finding an alternative way to express telepathy rather than bold type (it got very distracting). But of course that is just one opinion and it is up to you.
I look forward to reading more when I get a chance.
Regards,
Ani

jhj75 wrote 999 days ago

Very exceptional writing! I love the concept and have thought about it myself in the past (i.e. how to grant someone all-encompassing powers and how they would use them if they had them). I have to admit, given my horror bent, that the story would definitely go a different direction than yours :) I love your writing and the opening scene and it made me want to read more. I read the first few chapters very quickly and loved the voice of the main characters. Great job!

Fred Le Grand wrote 999 days ago

Hi,
I read this and found it hard to stop!
Stunning and one of the best reads on Authonomy.
I can only think of two or three others on here who have your gift.
This is not hollow praise.
Fandabidosytastic.
Shelved and enjoyed.
Wow!
Best,
Fred

Ape of God wrote 1000 days ago

AN ABSOLUTE CREATIVE POWERHOUSE indeed... Great pitch, great cover, great prose style and narrative energy. This is fluent, charismatic and compelling stuff, and after loving the first three chapters I did (obedient pup that I am) skip to 15 and nod approvingly throughout. This is on my shelf in all its disturbing glory and I look forward to filling in the gap between 3 and 15... Best of luck with it!

Ivan ('Johnny Face-Ache')

PS I've been poking and prodding around your website, which is full of fine things. The Contact Theatre - ah, I remember it well...

Sandie Newman wrote 1001 days ago

This was truly amazing, I read some of chapter 1 and chapter 15 and it's just incredible, it completely messes with your head, Sal and real Sal, weird. Very well written and completely brilliant. Shelved.

Sandie
The Crown of Crysaldor

selase13 wrote 1001 days ago

This is an exceptional piece of work. You really get the reader into the heads of these kids, and it doesn't feel contrived for a second. I didn't want to stop reading! The descriptions are fantastic; I could almost feel MarvinMilton myself. Great, great stuff.

zan wrote 1002 days ago

Hi Ian,
Started reading The Monodreme. You have a curious title which I like, and a great pitch. I've always been fascinated by the idea of life on other planets - as a child, even now, and I think this theme is an undying one which always sells. You have a story with a difference - unique, novel ideas here. Your writing is very atmospheric, energetic and compelling. The dialogue is good and the names of your characters just seem so appropriate and natural in the setting you have created. I enjoyed the opening and your description of the alien creature in Ch. 2 is brilliant. Haven't read enough yet to make a more substantive comment but I like what I've read so far and look forward to reading on.
Best wishes with this,
Zan

Bob Steele wrote 1002 days ago

The monodreme has an atmospheric and tense opening and you writing brings out emotions and a sense of place very skilfully. There is a well thought out story that drew me in, with effective hooks to keep me interested. Happy to shelve this - well done.
My only minor gripe is that I don't think your pitch does the book full justice - I suggest you need more clues about what happens and the overall evolution of the book.

agaian wrote 1002 days ago

Hi

I found that this story didn't grab me as much as I expected. I found my attention wandering a little from the beginning. It may be that ithe first part is too densely written- perhaps over-written. Judging by the backing
you've already received, I'm obviously missing something, but I'm afraid I'll have to pass on it at present.
If you ever do decide to re-write the beginning, get back to me and I'd be happy to have another look. I'm sorry I can't be more positive at the moment

Anthony
('Houses of Sand')

LittleDevil wrote 1003 days ago

Brilliant. Highly original and well written. And for someone who isn't into science fiction and fantasy, you did a good job convincing me otherwise.
Well done
Good luck and best wishes with this, I think it will attract the attention of publishers soon.
Sue
(A Boy Called George)

scottkenny wrote 1003 days ago

Hi Ian. This has a peach of a theme. I'm sure publishers are always on the lookout for something different, so you are on to a winner here. You write well too, pacing the story at a good speed, not giving too much away while maintaining the interest. I'd check out the number of times the word 'well' appears in the first page - it stuck out a bit, I thought - but there was nothing else to complain about. Ch.15 reads well, though there might be room for some pruning. Best of luck, Scott.

EdenTyler wrote 1004 days ago

This is totally my type of book and I relate to the your characters really well. The way you open about Sal, those words are right out of conversations I have with people. So that hooked me right away. To add to that, your writing is great and the tension you build in the beginning is awesome. I couldn't not read on. In fact, I have somewhere I need to be right now, like 10 minutes ago, but I just had to read some more and comment. (And place this on my shelf!) Such good stuff -- I hope this shoots up the charts so even more people can read it. Love it!!
-Eden*

Henrik Harrysson wrote 1004 days ago

I am not the best judge of fantasy or stories aimed at the “young”, but having read the first two chapters, I do find this quite engaging.

It is coming across as something of a cross between a Greek myth, and an episode of, say Grange Hill. I like the mundaneness of the setting, presumably a fictionalised provincial England. The liens choice of location is strange, but then, by definition it is going to be.

I was surprised that his young new found friends were not more awestruck by the arrival of this extraterrestrial apparition.

The writing bounces along energetically and is deliberately informal – which enables it to get the qualities and personality of the young narrator across well. This chatty style allows us to accept a slightly less formal style of English, but at times I felt it could be tightened up a bit.

The form “Osmo and me” as in “Osmo and me remained standing” started to grate. The para beginning “I liked Sal… - mentions that she was “cute” four times.” OK he obviously liked her, but a bit repetitious.

Also “our retinas should have curled up” – but a retina IS curved.

I feel you’re on to an interesting and original story here, but perhaps one that needs a bit more work and tightening up.

I am happy to back it for its potential.

Simon Swift wrote 1004 days ago

Great idea Ian - the pitch is awesome! And I love the opening couple of chapters. Am really intrigued as to whether you can continue to pull it off. For now its going on the shelf cos it hooked me! Well done fella.
Simon

Bill Carrigan wrote 1006 days ago

Hello, I (Ian?) Moore,

Many thanks for shelving "The Doctor of Summitville." The least I can do in return, after saying how well you write, is to mention a few little things that might perfect your exciting prose. In Chapter 1:

I'd name the narrator earlier. You could insert, right after the third paragraph:

Turning to me, he cried, "Oh my God, George! What is it?"

In the phrase "without looking over our shoulders," change "shoulders" to "shoulder."

In the phrase "breathing the cold air so hard," delete "so hard." It's not incorrect, but weakens the sentence.

In "us carrying on without Sal," delete "us."

In "as if he was sitting," change "was" to "were" and in the same line, delete "as if he were" before "constipated."

In "without him realizing," change "him" to "his" (unless you want the narrator to sound more informal).

If you follow my first suggestion, delete "I was George," which seems awkward introduced that way.

Insert a comma after "laws of physics."

Change "always seem to be preceded by" to "always seem to follow."

Rewrite: Pee put his back against the wall, slumped down onto his bum, and croaked, "We're gonna die."

I think you should give a more thorough description of the "thing" your characters are involved with. But don't diminish your characters' reaction.

I'm sure you meant to say, "Me and Osmo looked at each other" and "I'm sure me and Osmo" instead of the more correct "Osmo and I Iooked." But if you write in kid talk, be careful to stay in character. Words like "perimeter" and "collective breath" could, I'm afraid, seem out of place. The alternative is to use an adult vocabulary but keep it simple.

These are just a few suggestions, Ian--something to think about. Don't let this fossilized editor cramp your style. Now on to the fabulous Chapter 15, and I'll comment when time permits.

The best to you, Bill



Maria Luisa Lang wrote 1006 days ago

Dear I Moore, The idea described in your pitch is very imaginative, and your first two chapters show you’re a highly talented writer: the opening--a chase with the prelude interwoven throughout--is arresting, and your “close encounter” is quite amazing. I’m in awe of how much you accomplish so quickly, and Milton, who wrote about God in Paradise Lost, is the perfect name for an alien dispensing divine powers--but I’m sure you know that.

On my shelf. Maria, The Pharaoh’s Cat

J&M JENSEN wrote 1007 days ago

Your narative voice is brilliant - it feels young, brave and somehow vulnerable too. Most importantly of all, her voice echoes in your mind after you've finished reading. That's a very special thing to achieve. I actually have no helpful suggestions I'm afraid - excellent stuff and heartily shelved!

M&J

Marko wrote 1007 days ago

Oh, I like this, I Moore. Read the first chapter and delighted to back it. 'A mindless panic expanded inside us like an airbag'. Great line.

"Do you think it's taken over her mind?" whispered Osmo. Did you intend to repeat this line?

Marko (Brief Encounters)

PS Thanks for the backing!

Cas P wrote 1009 days ago

Hi there.
Wow, what a ride. One minute you're reading a highly polished and compelling story about a bunch of kids who discover an alien, the next you've been plunged deep into the Universal Consciousness! Strangely gripping stuff. I usually like to try and find something constructive to say but this time I found myself stumped. 'Amazing' is about as constructive as I can be.
Which is why I'm simply going to shut up and shelve. In awe.
Cas.
(KING'S ENVOY)

Nicky Jones wrote 1009 days ago

Wow, Ian. What a masterpiece. I love it to bits! The second paragraph is brillianrt in itself, and "snapping our paralysis like a rib" is awsome. The description of the monodrome as it engulfs is very powerful indeed. All in all your writing is fab, no nit-picks whatsoever.

This work is profound. How you have drawn this together and presented in a tale is beyond me. Chapter 15 is mind blowing. You have something REALLY special here. BACKED with great pleasure. Nicky.

shawnette.nielson wrote 1009 days ago

I love this idea of the narrator being an onlooker to the main character, and not the main character herself. It adds a depth to the story that you couldn't have achieved if the narrator had been Sal herself. The writing is absolutely superb, the characters clear and interesting and fun and real. Bravo!

Backed.

Shawnette

Steve Ward wrote 1010 days ago

Ian,
You have some imagination! I was begging for dialogue, then you delivered mind-speak in bold face. Yeah I suppose MarvinMilton is a good name for a light that falls out of the sky and bestows magical powers.
Although, I prefer dialogue over narrative, I thought you did a great job getting a very imaginative story over to the reader. I enjoyed the read. The writing is very clean but I did see some adverbs that could go:
I sweated clamily.
Good luck with your book.
Steve Ward, Test Pilot's Daughter: Revenge

Rio Guzman wrote 1011 days ago

Hi Ian! Great opening! Excellent writing. Shelved! I plan to get back to it...to chapter 15

pialia wrote 1011 days ago

Ian:

I like that you chose to start this in third rather than first person. The perceptions of the other children make Sal's experience more mysterious, compelling. The writing is tight, yet descriptive and emotive. The pitch promises quite the conundrum, and I'm fully immersed in the story. Quite happy to shelve and read on.

Jeanne

KW wrote 1011 days ago

"The End of the World" is a great name for a first chapter. I mean, where can you go from there? "We weren't ourselves anymore, just running things." I guess your characters don't make jogging a daily routine, huh? Anyway, this running and running from the end of the world is different. I like the little competitive jab you threw in about position in the running order: first place, second place, etc. I mean, afterall, this was the end of the world! Then they go back to look for Sal who was kneeling in front of the glowing being: gutsy kids, eh?

This is very entertaining and moves along quite quickly. I think it's very good for the YA market. Actually, it's great for the OA (old adult) market. The only problem I have is with the digressions you make to fill in the background of the characters. It's not a bad technique and it's effective enough, but it kind of distracts me. Frankly, I'm more interested in knowing what the glowing thing is before I learn that the narrator used to write deep short stories when she was fourteen. Simply, what the fuck is happening to Sal? That's just a little too much of a distraction. I don't know, maybe, I just want instant gratification.

I love the detail of the glowing being floating gracefully, but then it loses its balance as it touches down. Not everything is perfect, eh? "By the way, he's telepathic."

This is fun. I enjoyed it immensely. I'll shelve so I can look later at what is in the famous Chapter 15.

Lucie Roberts wrote 1012 days ago

Hi there Ian. I’m here for the swap. I have to warn you that fantasy isn’t really my thing and this metaphysical stuff goes right over my head (I’m a down-to-earth-sort-of-noob :-). At the risk of upsetting some, I’m also not convinced that God is all that powerful either, but I get the gist (and like the idea of your pitch--original ;-). You write well too (IMHO) and with passion. I particularly like your imagery, the description of time standing still, the six billion minds all coalescing into one (I’m sorry I can’t describe it as well or as lyrically as you do!). What Sal does with the Gift is roxxor btw. I wasn’t certainly expecting that! Original, I wish all teenagers were that mature (yep, I’m a pessimist as well as a cynical noob :-(. Having read chapters 1 and 15 (and being fantasy-challenged), I couldn’t really ‘get’ into the characters or the story, but I can see how this would appeal to aficionados of the genre. I only have two tiny nits to pick with you, namely: wouldn’t George’s voice be breathless as well as “serious”? and I suspect that perhaps “All of the religions, including the atheists and the agnostics” should be rephrased (atheists and agnostics aren’t religions and neither are atheism or agnosticism ;-). I’m sorry not to have been of more help, I’m gonna try to make up by giving TM a spin on my shelf. Good luck :-).

fancie wrote 1012 days ago

You display your characters effortlessly and what a great storyline! My only suggestion would be to keep the story coming...I was into what this "shared dream" was really all about and you cut to describing the characters. I was willing to wait on the personality traits to find out what was going on. I have to admit, I skimmed over them to get to the happenings, then went back to get a clearer visual of the Sal and George. I liked that about the Klingon language by-the-way. lol Reading on, shelved.

fancie

Richard Allen wrote 1014 days ago

From the cover to the pitch to the end of the first chapter, this is a winner. I couldn't put the damn thing down. The characters (and names) and are so real you already think you know what they are going to do next. Sal, in particular. With her inquisitive mind how could she not open the suitcase. The narrative is excellent and the pace is perfect. There is some wonderful creativity at work here supported by mind bending rhetoric that will challenge even the most skeptical readers of SF. Sal Real and Sal Fake, I thought was so cool ( a word I rarely use). Your style of writing reminds me of Hebert and Asimov, intelligent, thought provoking, yet entertaining. Like a few works I have had the pleasure to read here, this novel belongs on a real shelf, the kind you find in your local bookstore.

Shelved.

Andrew S wrote 1014 days ago

A very impressive opening chapter. On my shelf.

I'm not a big fan of sci-fi/fantasy but I can see this doing well within this genre. You write with trmendous confidence which is very reassuring for the reader. The prose is very smooth with an appropriately conversational, almost chatty feel. The dialogue feels real and helps drive the scenes. Good sense of a well-conceived and pretty original storyline developing. Nicely handled end to ch1 with a great hook in last line (although I'd drop the 'conversationally'??)

A couple of points for you to mull over:

I really didn't like the use of the name 'Pee'. It felt rather forced and a bit self-indulgent. Moreover, it served as a distraction all the way through the chapter and prevented me from fully engaging with the characters/narrative. It's probably just me, but something to think about.

Although I liked the first person narrative, once or twice it felt a little distant for this type of POV. Lines like 'I sweated clammily under my coat, while above the neckline my ears glowed with the cold' don't sit comfortably with this POV. I think the narrator might be aware of wetness/heat but, given the context, I don't think it would register in the way you express it. Just a thought.

A very polished, confident piece of work, though. Best of luck. Thanks.

JohnRL1029 wrote 1015 days ago

Your descriptions are vivid magic! "Fear clogged out throats, oozed out of our pores, pounded in our brains." This is a cult classic in the works. Love the characters and the dialogue. "Human development, if you average it out around the globe, is about equivalent to that of a teenager." Genius stuff here. I'm guessing your English teachers though the world of your writing as well. Sal is awesome. SHELVED!

Phil Rowan wrote 1015 days ago

Accomplished writing, Ian. I went from 1 to 15 and now I want to go back and take in the whole story. Backed with pleasure and wishing you well. Phil Rowan (Weimar Vibes)

JohnnyVee wrote 1015 days ago

Hi Ian,
Some thoughts as I read through…
At first I’m put off by the multiple introspection (fear clogged our throats etc) and I hope that the author has some clever explanation for this. Is this character a mind-reader? An empath? An alien?
And we’re off and running with obvious terror for eleven paragraphs and a few lines of dialogue - yet by the end of this frantic dash, I’m non the wiser as to what they were running from.
I get the feeling that this should be pared back a little.

Next up we have some great characterisation for Sal, followed by the encounter with the `light`

Overall impressions of this first chapter are thus; I like your style, though would suggest slight paring to increase the pace a little. I’m also wondering if this would work better with just Sal and George and the other characters removed? At this time, they simply hang in the background and are more of a distraction.

Chapter two brings us the alien description which is pretty darn cool as is the alien `voice` LOVE IT!

Then I just had to jump to chapter 15 to see what the cherry-picking fuss was all about…very nice indeed!

Overall, for me, you can certainly tell a story and you do characterisation well, however, I do think that paring back your prose by 20% would produce a much sharper tale. This is only one opinion of course so do ignore me if nothing resonates.

Backed!
All best,
Johnny

JamieKate wrote 1016 days ago

I LOVED the first few paragraphs, and after that I just had to keep reading. I loved every bit that I read, and I have no critiques, which is pretty unusual. Your characters are familiar and yet unique and your prose is very smooth...ah! I just loved it.
Shelved!
Jamie

123