Book Jacket

 

rank 684
word count 84913
date submitted 22.10.2010
date updated 20.04.2012
genres: Popular Culture, Instructional, Har...
classification: universal
incomplete

Holistic Recovery from Schizophrenia: A Mother and Son Journey

Rossa Forbes

A mother's quantum quest for healing, asking big questions and getting surprising anwers.

 

Chris's journey becomes his mother's journey when she starts to investigate why he is not getting better, and why, after two years in a day program he is still an enigma to the doctors. The journey takes some unusual detours into modalities of healing and thought that are not part of what is considered the proper medical treatment for schizophrenia today. To help heal her son, she first must learn that his condition is not a pathological disease. Part coming-of-age story, part do-it-yourself manual, Holistic Recovery from Schizophrenia shows where mental health treatment is headed at the dawn of the 21st century.

 
rate the book

to rate this book please Register or Login

 

tags

alexander technique, assemblage point, bipolar disorder, eastern mysticism, energy medicine, energy psychology, family constellation therapy, iatrogen...

on 23 watchlists

86 comments

 

Text Size

Text Colour

Chapters

1

report abuse

Growing Concerns

CONTENTS

 

Chapter 1    Growing Concerns

Chapter 2    More Signs and Symptoms

Chapter 3    Talking to God and All

Chapter 4    Diagnosis

Chapter 5    My Name is Legion

Chapter 6    The Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH)

Chapter 7    Androgyny, the Divine Spark and Nihilism

Chapter 8    Good-bye CAMH, Hello Belle Idée

Chapter 9    Start with Childhood

Chapter 10    Reflections on Psychiatrists

Chapter 11    Orthomolecular Medicine and Beyond

Chapter 12    Energy Medicine and Vibrational Energy

Chapter 13    Medication Wars

Chapter 14    The Never-Ending Battle

Chapter 15    The Levels of Healing

Chapter 16    The Other Psychiatrists

Chapter 17     The Assemblage Point

Chapter 18    All the World’s a Stage

Chapter 19    Expressed Emotion

Chapter 20    The Practical Assemblage Point

Chapter 21    The Mother as the Observer

Chapter 22    The Same Procedure as Before

Chapter 23     Fleetingly Improvised Men

Chapter 24    Hearing Voices

Chapter 25       The Ties That Bind

Chapter 26    Family Constellations

Chapter 27    Breakthrough

Chapter 28    The Alexander Technique

Chapter 29    More Twists on the Recovery Rollercoaster

Chapter 30    The Expressed Emotion of Acting

Chapter 31     Up is Down and Down is Up

Chapter 32    Homemade Soteria

Chapter 33    Back in the Bin

Chapter 34    Colère

Chapter 35    The Tomatis Method

Chapter 36    Sound Therapy: In the Beginning was the Word

Chapter 37    Out-of-Body

Chapter 38    Pioneers in the New World Health Organization

Chapter 39    Public Dreams, Private Myths

Chapter 40    Desert Matrix

Chapter 41    CHAPTER UNDER CONSTRUCTION

 

 

 

“Why does anybody tell a story?” she once asked, even though she knew the answer. “It does indeed have something to do with faith,” she said, “faith that the universe has meaning, that our little human lives are not irrelevant, that what we choose or say or do matters, matters cosmically.”

—Madeleine L’Engle

 

In September 2002, on the morning Chris[1] was due to leave for university, he still had not packed his bags. Clothes were strewn all over his bedroom and his suitcase was empty. He seemed dazed. I yelled at him to begin packing his bags for the year ahead. The taxi would be arriving in half an hour. Chris had always been so on track and capable. He never needed reminding about what to do . . . until recently. I threw all of his clothes and necessities into two suitcases and slammed them shut, doubting how he was going to survive on his own if he couldn’t even pack a suitcase.

Half an hour later, I watched from the window as Chris and his father loaded the suitcases into the cab and headed for the airport and their flight to Canada, where Chris was to begin undergraduate work at the University of Toronto. Tears rolled down my cheeks. Something was wrong. A dedicated, organized, and intellectually ambitious student during high school, Chris had somehow lost his edge in the past year. For the first time ever, he had needed prodding to complete his work. His final exam results in the International Baccalaureate (IB) program fell short of his teachers’ expected results.

It was an uneasy time, and where his father and I might otherwise have let Chris make the trip to Toronto by himself, we opted instead to have his father accompany him.

Our current home, Geneva, Switzerland, where my husband, Ian, and I work for international organizations, is renowned for many things, among them proximity to the European Centre for Nuclear Research (CERN). CERN is the birthplace of the World Wide Web, which can be thought of as the earthbound equivalent of the Akashic records, an ancient Sanskrit term describing an ethereal library of all knowledge—thought, word, and action—that can be accessed through the subconscious mind.[2] In the winter of 2002, CERN began work on the installation of a Large Hadron Collider (LHC), a super-duper particle accelerator, which was completed in 2008. This particle accelerator is intended to recreate the conditions in the first one-trillionth of a second following the “big bang,” thereby explaining how matter first clumped together to form the cosmos. Like so many things in my voyage of insight into the schizophrenic condition, the relevance of this quantum physics event and the God particle to Chris's situation only became clearer to me later.

Geneva is also known for its gray winters. Stratus clouds form a blanket over Lac Léman and the sun doesn’t shine for months on end. Night falls early. Winter 2002 seemed particularly gloomy, especially at dinnertime. The tea lights on the dining room table flickered like votive candles. Chris stopped joining in dinner conversation. Alex and Taylor, his younger brothers, were also somewhat subdued, but not to the same extent. Ian seemed more intent on eating than talking. When I spoke, Chris would turn his head every so often and silently put his fingers to his lips to hush me. Dinners became quiet affairs. I now think the tea lights were a mistake, though I preferred them to the harsh glare of the overhead chandelier. Tea lights only emphasized the gloom.

While I was uneasy at these changes in Chris's behavior, my first real scare came on an airplane. In December 2001, Chris and I flew to England where he had an interview scheduled at Cambridge University. Cambridge demands that its incoming students know exactly what they want to study for the next three years (e.g. history or chemistry), and to have excelled intellectually compared to their peers while in high school. Chris had applied for a place in chemistry. Despite being an excellent math student he was not particularly interested in career paths like engineering or computer science. In his application to the university, he had expressed the vague notion of wanting to understand the essence of matter. I considered that a tad presumptuous and a bit strange, more like the musings of an ancient alchemist than a modern chemist. 

The link to alchemy was another clue that I failed to grasp. Swiss psychiatrist Carl Jung saw alchemy as the Western equivalent to the practice of yoga; those practicing it were, in essence, embarking on a spiritual path. Chris's strange interest could be seen as the beginning of a spiritual struggle to heal and to integrate his divided self into a stable whole. But, of course, I did not know that then.

The interview at Cambridge didn’t go well. A postmortem conversation I had with Chris revealed that the interviewer thought that Chris lacked confidence. I had noticed that his confidence had been waning over the past year, but couldn’t pinpoint its onset to anything other than the academic stresses of the final year of high school. 

Part of our reason for coming to Cambridge was to enjoy spending time together, so Chris and I wandered the university's hallowed grounds, eventually settling down to a pub beer. The next day we took the Easyjet flight from Luton to Geneva. We left grey foggy England and a short hour and a half later began the descent through the stratus layers to Geneva. The plane was within inches of touching down when Chris suddenly cried out, touching his hand to his temple in pain. As soon as the plane landed, the pain in his head disappeared. We went immediately to the first aid office at the airport. “Un mystère,” said the nurse.

In the days that followed, Chris went twice to the family doctor. He found nothing conclusive as a cause. Nothing to worry about, he reassured us.

Over the next few months, Chris began to check his temple regularly. He kept tapping the tender spot, saying it felt like an indentation. Taylor, who was then thirteen, cheerfully piped up that “if it were a tumor, it would be pushing out.”

What the doctor didn’t pick up on was possible problems with the prefrontal cortex, the executive area of the brain that deals with complex planning, personality, and social behavior. The executive function relates to "abilities to differentiate among conflicting thoughts, determine good and bad, better and best, same and different, future consequences of current activities, working towards a defined goal, prediction of outcomes, expectation based on actions, and social ‘control.’”[3]

A Beautiful Mind, the film about Nobel laureate John Nash’s descent into schizophrenia, appeared in Geneva theatres in July 2002. Ian was particularly interested in seeing it because he had once heard John Nash speak at the American Economics Association convention. So, off the family went  all but Alex, our sixteen-year-old, who, now that school was out for the summer, slept most days and partied with his friends most nights.

I knew nothing about schizophrenia other than its diagnosis is supposed to be very bad news. To the best of my knowledge I had never personally or even peripherally known anyone with schizophrenia. So I was surprised when Nash’s roommate turned out to be a hallucination.

The movie was great, but I was left with a niggling worry.

Taylor picked up on it. “Ha, he keeps tapping his head just like Chris does.”

Or did. Chris had stopped the repetitive feathery touches to his temple a couple of months earlier. At the time, I didn’t make a conscious connection between what John Nash went through and Chris’s symptoms. There seemed to be a logical physical cause for Chris’s temple problem (the change in the plane’s altitude) and he seemed to have recovered from it. I wasn’t familiar with psychosis or primed to look for it, so I had missed such subtleties as Chris putting his fingers to his lips to keep his mother quiet at the dinner table so that the pope could get a word in. The pope first spoke to Chris during a church service, Chris revealed to me several years later.

A week later, Chris and Ian were talking in low voices in the bedroom. I crept to the closed door and listened. “Ophélie is a beautiful girl and . . .” Ian’s voice faded away. Ophélie, the daughter of a friend of mine, was a classmate of Chris’s. I had a sense of foreboding—with good reason, as it turned out. Chris wanted to marry Ophélie. He was unsure what to do about it. He wanted to find a job in Geneva to support her. University for him was nowhere in the picture, despite the fact that he was supposed to be leaving in a month for Toronto. Ophélie was leaving for university in London in a few months, a reality that was unbearable for Chris 

Marry Ophélie? To my knowledge, they hadn’t even been dating! This was strange. Scary, even. Out of character. I tried to rationalize that young people fall all the time. I can still recall the pain of first love and how mind and mood altering it can be. My intuition told me that where Chris was concerned, there was something highly unusual going on. There had been no lead-up to this sudden declaration of love.

The rest of the weekend I lay on my bed, staring into space. On Monday, I met Irene, Ophélie’s mother, for our usual lunch and brought up the fact that Chris was seeing Ophélie. Irene quickly let me know that Ophélie only thought of him as a friend. I asked myself how his mind could leap to marriage when his romantic relationship with Ophélie was one-sided. There was nothing solid enough here to justify forgoing university. Irene confided that she had recently learned that Chris’s friends had been worried about him.

I felt sick. Worried about him? What had they noticed? Why hadn’t someone said something? When I thought more about it, I realized how quiet Chris had become over the past year. When his friends came over, Chris just sat there, not saying much. The others would be chatting and laughing, but not Chris. He had become, well, sort of plastic in his looks and speech. He didn’t smile much, though he didn’t seem depressed, and his face had a wan look to it. His speech was somewhat mechanical and devoid of interesting observations to me at least. I attributed this impoverishment of speech to an intense academic year, but then I recalled other worrisome instances when friends of the family telephoned and Chris answered the phone, there was no warmth of recognition in his voice. 

For the next two weeks, Chris took the train to Ophélie’s house, returning on a train later in the evening. Would he propose marriage? The unexpectedness and the depth of his life-altering plan scared me. He was clearly wearing his heart on his sleeve and he was going down fast, like a bird shot in midair by Cupid’s dart. This wasn’t the Chris “in love” that I would have expected, if the path of love is predictable at all.

“Why not take Chris to China with you?” I asked Ian one day. This was a practical diversion. Ian was travelling to Beijing for work and had air miles to spare. Brilliant! Chris would be distracted by the new and strange. By the time he got back, ten days without Ophélie would have elapsed, the situation would have resolved itself somehow, and Chris would be that much closer to starting university. Life would move on.

From Ian’s perspective, the trip to Beijing did not go well. Chris took no interest in the extra day of sight-seeing Ian scheduled, choosing to sit in the tour bus while the rest of the group visited an acupuncture center. Ian was frustrated. Ian and Chris quarreled often, which was something new.

When Chris returned from China, Ian and I did not discuss Ophélie with Chris and concentrated instead on helping him prepare for university, without any enthusiasm or effort on Chris' part. We were very concerned that Chris was about to ruin his first year of university, which he hadn't even started.

Based on his IB results, Chris was eligible to claim first-year university credits for biology, chemistry, and math. In Ian's and my opinion, an IB course is no equivalent for a first year university course, particularly in the maths and sciences. Entering a second year course not having done the first year prerequisite is fraught with peril. Canadian university courses often last a full year and cover a lot of territory very quickly at the beginning. 

Seeing how determined he was to claim first year credits, our compromise suggestion was that Chris could claim credit for a course as long as he was planning not to pursue that subject area further. He agreed to our suggestion. However, Chris had also decided that he wanted to take a first-year physics course, despite the fact that he had not taken physics in his last two years of high school. This could be done, the university informed us, as long as the student is good in math and is willing to work. “Okay, if you insist, Ian and I said to Chris, “but whatever you do, do NOT claim credit for first-year math.”

Chris's desire to leap ahead without doing the preliminaries was baffling to us. He exhibited a coolly detached impression of his own abilities, seeming to convey that his mind was far more capable than the minds of mere mortals. He projected an aura that he already knew all the information that was needed and that he didn’t have to go through the steps. This was a new trait in him that was at odds with his seeming lack of confidence that I and others had observed. Since Chris is not a boisterous personality given to expressing his moods and opinions, this particular trait could well have remained hidden. Psychiatrists call this trait grandiosity.

A case in point was driving lessons. Chris had enrolled that summer in driving school. Students are eligible for a one-day course at a practice driving range when they feel they are close to taking their driver's test. Chris decided to take the course midway through his driving lessons. His practice session was cut short by an irate instructor who told him to go home and come back when he was ready. Ian and I were astounded. We were also angry with him. What was he thinking? Did he actually think he knew everything there was to know about driving?

The possibility that Chris might be mentally ill didn’t occur to Ian or me at that time. My experience in raising three sons and entertaining their young male friends had been that they all have an inflated sense of their own skills, especially where vehicles or sports prowess is concerned. If they go skiing, they brag about their imminent plans to do the black diamond runs, even if they are novices. They all seem to think that getting their drivers license will take a matter of days and they will pass with flying colors on the first try. Well, we hoped Chris was just demonstrating that kind of bravado. Maybe it was even a good sign. He had always been so compliant and a follower of the rules.

The University of Toronto is huge, but there are colleges within the university that are small and allow the students to relax and get to know people in a less threatening environment. Of these, Trinity College has a reputation as one of the best. It attracts students who are ambitious and engaged. Chris was faltering in both categories when he entered in the fall of 2002. He wanted to skip Trinity’s orientation week. Ian and I insisted otherwise. How could he possibly think that skipping orientation week was a good idea? What was he thinking? Orientation week provides an opportunity for students make new friends and learn to feel a little bit at home in a strange new setting. There would be toga parties, beer fests, and other college rituals.

Chris went to orientation, and enjoyed himself. Subsequent letters home indicated he was still enjoying himself and taking advantage of all that the college and university had to offer. He rang home about a week into the start of his classes.

“Mum, I want to get a credit for my math course and go into second-year math. This course is too easy. I’ve covered most of the work already.”

By then I was fed up with his unusual attitude in the face of common sense and replied testily, “Go ahead. It’s your life.”

With Chris away at Trinity, I turned to the task of cleaning his room, thinking all the while of Chris's puzzling behavior with every photo and term paper and scrap of his recent life that I uncovered.

As I cleaned, I reflected on Chris's recent phone call seeking our permission to take a second year math course. Where did this constant asking for permission come from?  Permission-seeking seems like a timid trait, but Chris was not so much timid as apologetic. I didn’t understand his self-effacement. I tried to correct these habits over the years by pointing out that apologies were not needed or wanted and that neither was his father's or my permission in most cases. The direct approach produced no change in his character. Later I tended to regard the apologizing and permission-seeking as apathy, but I was confused whether it was apathy or ambivalence.

Apathy means lacking interest or energy; being unwilling to take action especially over a matter of importance. Ambivalence is having two opposing feelings at the same time or being uncertain about how you feel.

Can apathy/ambivalence be demonstrated in the womb, I wondered? Perhaps so.

I became pregnant on March 30, 1983, in Ottawa, Canada, where Ian and I had moved after we met in graduate school in Toronto. I remember the date exactly because I heard a “ping” of “mission accomplished” when sperm met egg. So it came as no surprise to me when the ultrasound set the due date as December 10. It also came as no surprise to me that “he” was confirmed by the ultrasound as a “he.” The landscape of my dreams during that time featured babies dressed in blue.

After the first ping of joy, we heard nothing from Chris in the womb.

“Lots of movement?” asked Dr. Lee, during his energetic monthly prodding of my stomach.

Well, what exactly was a lot of movement? Chris was my first. How was I supposed to know what’s considered movement? I agreed that there was movement, because mother and baby were otherwise healthy. Every so often I felt perhaps a finger move. Once I lay on the floor and rested a book on my stomach, just to see Chris shrug it off, but that was the extent of physical exertion on his part.

The due date came and went. I was visiting Dr. Lee weekly at this point and he asked if I wanted to be induced.

“No, let’s just wait and see what happens,” I said. “No sense in messing up his horoscope. He’ll come when he’s ready.”

I trudged to the hospital each week thereafter for an electronic fetal monitoring test where I ingested orange juice to stimulate fetal movement. Chris was still hanging in there, but the tests showed there was no cause for alarm.

“Be prepared for a girl,” said the technician. “High heartbeat.”

New Year’s came and went. The days dragged on. Finally, in the early hours of January 6, 1984, there was, at last, some activity, although my waters hadn’t broken. Chris was still in no hurry to make his appearance. Was he being apathetic or ambivalent about the deadline? He was by then twenty-six days overdue.

The next twenty-four hours at the hospital were rough. Chris clearly wasn’t in any rush. I staggered up and down the hospital corridors, breathing out of sync, despite my prenatal coaching. Ian gently instructed me to remember our rhythm and I snarled back at him to just let me get on with it. Exhausted, I finally opted for the epidural and jettisoned the idea of natural child birth. The epidural slowed the birth process down considerably.

“Be prepared for a girl,” the nurse warned as she removed the fetal monitor.

“No, it’s a boy,” I shot back confidently.

And, of course, he was.

“All ten fingers and toes,” Dr. Lee crowed. “His test scores are healthyand here's the proof that his ultrasound due date of December 10 was correct. His fingers are peeling.”

In the next two days Chris opened his eyes for the first time in my presence. I was enchanted by the deep blue. About a week later, his tiny hands unclenched. Only in retrospect do I find it unusual that he was clenching his hands for so long. It now signifies tension to me.

My daydreaming about Chris's birth was interrupted by the discouraging scene in his room. I remembered his hastily packed suitcase, a fumbled attempt to begin the beginning of the rest of his life. Chris used to be pretty neat and I didn't have to nag him about cleaning up his room, but that, too, had changed in the past year. Strewn throughout the clutter were torn bits and pieces of papers.

When I picked one up, I saw Ophélie’s name and address at the top.

It was a strange love poem, and reminded me of something a knight might pen for his lady. He wrote about testing his strength, as if he was planning to undertake a series of extraordinary challenges in order to win her love. I reasoned that the words were no more bizarre than many rock lyrics and Chris was a keen musician, so it all kind of made sense. It was beautiful and poetic and oddly meaningful. Despite some misgivings, I was impressed by the feeling, the striving, and the sheer energy in what I read.  

I picked up the rest of the crumpled papers and threw most of them away. I hoped that whatever had inspired this outpouring had also gone away. I was wrong. This was only the beginning.

In the years to come I would notice many things about Chris that could be considered part of an extended, heroic journey. At the time I had never even heard of mythologist Joseph Campbell, author of The Hero with a Thousand Faces, who wrote that all great myths share, to some extent or other, the same hero's journey: the hero, living in ordinary circumstances, receives a call (hearing perhaps a voice), that catapults him into the land of the supernatural. He endures many tests and hardships, possibly even suffering spiritual death in order to be resurrected. During this ordeal he gains special knowledge that he may choose to share with others if he accepts the challenge of returning to the land from where he came. The journey home is fraught with peril, too. The gift that he brings back will be used to enrich the world.

Campbell's hero's journey is a descent experience, a dark night of the soul, told time over time by many people, including the psychiatrist Carl Jung, and can be seen also as a metaphor for serious illness.  In Christian theology, the dark night of the soul is illuminated by an ever present light, which eventually will lead the hero to union with the Divine and ultimately, self-knowledge. Sometimes the hero is accompanied on his journey by another, who undergoes a parallel experience. I was privileged to share this journey and to discover that psychiatric illness can be a metaphor for growth his and mine. But before growth could happen, first we had to descend to the abyss.

I grabbed my notebook to take with me. This journey needed documentation.


 

[1]In this book, names of members of the family and of all treating physicians and psychologists are fictitious.

[2] The library houses the collection of universal truth, to which all people have access, and which all religions and shamanic traditions have acknowledged in some way.

[3] Wikipedia definition of prefrontal cortex, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prefrontal_cortex, 09/2008

Chapters

1

report abuse

To leave comments on this or any book please Register or Login

subscribe to comments for this book
Bill Carrigan wrote 18 days ago

Dear Rossa-- Your "Holistic Recovery from Schizophrenia" (recommended by Petra) is an informative, detailed description of a mother's prolonged experience with her son's illness. Told from a layman's point of view, it expresses a perceptive insight into the symptoms, diagnosis, and varied treatments of this mysterious disorder. It rings with authenticity and level-headed assessment of the current psychiatric situation and leaves one with the impression that your son's recovery may have resulted from this or that regimen, your own dedication, or natural causes. In any event, your book is a contribution to understanding of the disorder and its therapy. --Congratulations on Chris's care and your superb narration,

Bill Carrigan
("The Doctor of Summitville")

Six Foot Bonsai wrote 51 days ago

Hello Rossa. I have a 21 year-old son and a 19 year-old step son. One is very relaxed (too much for my taste); while the other is constantly ranting about politics and religion.

I'm reading this with eyes wide open. It's a very useful, honest account. I'll keep reading. i put it on my bookshelf. Thank you! Stacy G.

strachan gordon wrote 67 days ago

An extremely involving and perturbing first chapter , which fills one with anxiety about the ultimate fate of your son - you are so right when you say the average extrovert adolescent male exhibits traits which at times are hardly distinguishable from schizophrenia , but ,of course ,is all a matter of degree rather than fundamental nature . Watchlisted and starred . Would you be able to look at the first chapter of my novel 'A Buccaneer' w which is set amongst Pirates in the 17th century , with best wishes from Strachan Gordon

Rossa Forbes wrote 95 days ago

Dear David,
Thank you so much for your taking the time to read a few chapters and for your comments. I've been doing a lot of revisions to the book in the last few days, and it's possible that you caught the Table of Contents when it was also being revised. When I went back to check your comment about the Alexander Technique chapter, the Alexander Technique is the correct title for Chapter 27 and it is also briefly mentioned in a subsequent chapter. I've fixed the long gap that you noticed, so thank you. I can see now how it would be easy to skip over the first chapter. I've tweaked the first page make it clearerthat Chris is my son. Thanks for pointing this out.
Best regards, and good luck!
Rossa

I highly recommend this book, not only for people who are interested in learning about alternative treatments for mental illness, but for readers who are interested in holistic therapies in general, and in personal growth. I've read all the available chapters, and thank you for your candid sharing. Five stars.
Jilaine Tarisa
A Moment of Time

Rossa Forbes wrote 95 days ago

Jilaine,
Thank you very much for your recommendation. I am honored to be recommended by an Editor's Desk author!
Best regards,
Rossa

I highly recommend this book, not only for people who are interested in learning about alternative treatments for mental illness, but for readers who are interested in holistic therapies in general, and in personal growth. I've read all the available chapters, and thank you for your candid sharing. Five stars.
Jilaine Tarisa
A Moment of Time

David Price wrote 96 days ago

Rossa, this is a compelling manuscript, one that deserves to be widely read. As you seek to find answers to your son's strange behaviour, your concern and love for him shines through.

Time has so far prevented me from reading more than several chapters. (This includes the one on Alexander Technique, a particular interest of mine. By the way, it appears that it is wrongly listed in the table of contents, you write about in Chapters 25 and 26, not 27.) But I am happy to give it 5 stars, and hope to read more soon.

Oh, I also nearly missed the first chapter, due to the large gap between it and the table of contents. And I was also struck (unless I missed it) that you appear not to call 'Chris' your son in the opening chapters. Perhaps for the sake of clarity, it would be helpful to do so.

Thanks again for your support of 'Master Act'.

David

Jilaine Tarisa wrote 97 days ago

I highly recommend this book, not only for people who are interested in learning about alternative treatments for mental illness, but for readers who are interested in holistic therapies in general, and in personal growth. I've read all the available chapters, and thank you for your candid sharing. Five stars.
Jilaine Tarisa
A Moment of Time

Diwrite wrote 124 days ago

This isn't the sort of thing I'd pick up, but I found it really easy to read and quickly became absorbed.
I hope a lot of people read this.

Starred and shelved with best wishes.

Diana
Pascual's Birthday

Rebel Guru wrote 125 days ago

Hey Rossa,
I read your chapters, I enjoyed your clear narrative in writing, you expressed your own mind and have reflected your own emotional intelligence and limitations beautifully. You are honest about your feelings and show the reader how we all are limited by our conditioning, IMO this humility is the first step in healing our minds...
You have shown modern medicine and science as for now is very limited in understanding the human mind.
Doctor's who have approached psychology and psychiatric problems holistically have achieved better results than just dependence on drugs... wonderful message for mothers/ parents facing your situation.
I want to read chapter 31 to 36. look forward to read when you post them.
Since I am involved in meditation, would love to share some thoughts with you,
Our human mind is psychologically limited by our habitual thinking. All mental disorders, except a few biological and chemical imbalances are present in everyone of us, but most of us manage to stay in balance due to our adaptation to practical reality. I find people who are sensitive and emotionally intelligent loose objectivity sometimes because human life is mentally not very balanced. Simply adapting to stupid mindsets causes conflicts within naturally sensitive minds.
We are naturally gentle compassionate and joyous brains...our conditioning/training has caused us to loose our natural emotional wisdom, our brain is not healthy because we have adapted to live as we learnt.
Our Body( Brain included) heals naturally, it adapts to natural deformities, but in case of our mind, we need to learn how to use our brain naturally, then we heal naturally.
Your book is highly starred by me, and I wish you success since your message is wonderful for parenting in different situations we parents face,

Take care, stay warm and joyous,
love,
Arun.

Wanttobeawriter wrote 146 days ago

HOLISTIC RECOVERY
This is a story that needs to be told as so many other people out there must be wondering about the same things as the author: are the subtle changes they see in their child something to worry about or not? Your writing style is flowing and easy to read. I like the way you begin this by recounting the first signs of schizophrenia and then, how this becomes a family condition, not a single person one. I’m adding this to my shelf. Wanttobeawriter: Who Killed the President?

Justis Call wrote 211 days ago

Wow, what an incredible and exceptionally well-written story. I have only touched the surface of your book, yet have found it intriguing, compelling, fascinating. Many in today's world would do well to learn from your story, your son's life, and your family's triumphs.

Thank you for sharing,
Justis Call
Snow Bound

Rossa Forbes wrote 241 days ago

Hi, Cool,
I really appreciate your taking the time to read the book, and I hope I can do the same for yours. I am finding that I am swamped with work at the moment and falling down in my authonomy obligations. But, I do keep track of books. For the time being I have put yours on my WL for future reference. My manuscript is not finished, I still have to fix the final chapters and find a compelling ending.
Thanks very much for your support.
...Rossa

Cool1 wrote 246 days ago

Rossa: I finished reading your book as it is quite compelling.
Best of luck,
Rich-Cool1

Author apart from the rest wrote 247 days ago

Rossa,

Your book would be a help to anyone with mental illness. Schizophrenia is such a complex and touchy subject; however your book has put this illness into perspective, offering hope and help to those who deal with the subject. Please keep up the superb writing and know that I have placed you on my shelff....

Cool1 wrote 248 days ago

Rossa: I have read the first six chapters of your book, as well as the last and found it to be an interesting account of your son's struggle with Schizophrenia. I am glad to hear he has something that works for him. I work with people in supported housing that have been released from institutions. We don't see many success stories, but have a couple of people in management level positions that function well with their illness. It seems your son may be among the lucky ones that found what works for him.
Cool1

strachan gordon wrote 249 days ago

Hello Rossa , I have been extremely interested in your book about your son and have found it very gripping . i have actually read two chapters when I normally only read one. Extremely well written , the tone cool , but very alert and full of insight - it also raises the problem that , to an extent , all adolescent boys elicit symptoms of schizophrenia with their arrogance , bravado and grandiosity - you obviously know your subject area . I wonder if you would be able to look at the first chapter of my novel 'A Buccaneer' , which is set amongst Pirates in the 17th century . Watchlisted and starred .with best wishes from Strachan Gordon.

elenio wrote 274 days ago

loved what I've read so far, looking forward to reading the rest. You take a fresh new approach to an age old condition.

leelah wrote 283 days ago

Hi Rossa, these are familiar themes for me, and i am grateful that books like this will show people that holistic medicine has NOT got the final answer. As an expressive arts therapist, I have used a mixture of energy-therapy, art modalities and A Course in Miracles - metaphysics. These are also methods I have used on myself - and for me, the metaphysics was the most helpful way.
I love that we are living in these times, where new ways of thinking are flowering the dry landscapes of "take a pill."
I love that I can read about it books like yours, where one can see that your journey together is a spiritual one.
I so hope this is published!
Best of luck!
Leelah saachi, "When fear comes home to love"

HayleyK wrote 300 days ago

I just signed up to this site today and have skimmed through some other peoples' work, but yours has captivated my attention like no other. I've only read a few chapters, but I will be sure to invest more time once I have the chance. Please keep up the great work! I think the disease is very misunderstood and it's wonderful that you are shedding light on the concept. My mother suffers from borderline personality disorder, and it did not make for an easy childhood, considering my father is a cardiologist and very dedicated to his work. This has inspired me to start writing about my own experiences as a child with a parent with a mental disorder. Thank you!

Walden Carrington wrote 300 days ago

Rossa,
I read your introduction with great interest as I have a disdain for the pharmaceutical industry and its quest for profit to the detriment of human health. Natural cures exist which they don't want you to know about to quote a bestselling author who has exposed the greed of this industry and the harm it has caused to people due to the harmful side effects of medications they are continually inventing. Your true story of Chris's recovery from schizophrenia without the use of medication is harrowing and inspiring. It has great practical benefit to anyone who is schizophrenic or knows someone with schizophrenia. I applaud your bravery in sharing this private account with the public and know many would stand to benefit from its publication. Many medications which are frequently prescribed to treat mental illness cause more harm than good due to the dreadful side effects. The drug companies who are inventing more medications in a quest for profit are unconcerned about the natural treatments which would make many prescription medications less profitable if the public were educated about the natural ways of treating illnesses and disorders which are commonly treated with medications that provide no real cure, but simply mask the symptoms and often create other health problems due to the side effects. Holistic Recovery from Schizophrenia: A Mother and Son Journey is a story which should be shared with the public as any recovery program which doesn't involve the conventional prescription of medications should so the public is aware there are alternatives to how the medical establishment treats these conditions.

Walden Carrington
Titanic: Rose Dawson's Story

Stark Silvercoin wrote 326 days ago

I was fascinated by author Rossa Forbes book, Holistic Recovery from Schizophrenia: A Mother and Son Journey. I have a family member who works with people who have mental problems and the really scary part is that over the past ten years, the number of people brought into the institution has tripled. There are more patients there now than at any time in history, and those numbers are growing. From a ground level view like that, its easy to tell that something is wrong. Nobody is being cured, and the number of mentally ill people keeps growing almost exponentially.

Author Rossa Forbes also has a ground level view, within her own family. And instead of accepting that lifetime drug treatment is the answer for her son, she goes on a journey to find a way to actually cure his schizophrenia, not merely treat it.

Although the book could be considered a self-help manual, it’s a lot more personal than that. I feel like I know both Rossa and Chris from reading their story, and I wish them the best.

A book like this needs to be published. The system today is all about containment of the problem, but that is not working. Something is wrong with the current treatment, and I hope books like this one open up the minds of doctors working in the field, and provide comfort and advice for those affected by mental illness.

John Breeden II
Old Number Seven

Heavensent wrote 337 days ago

Rossa, Many thanks for your reply it is heartening to read of Chris' progress.

Good luck with the book

Rossa Forbes wrote 338 days ago

Heavensent, my goodness, you must be a first. Thanks for getting through all the chapters to date. I have a couple of more interesting chapters that I haven't uploaded yet that are about the sound therapy, and then I got stuck because I wanted to make all kinds of links with schizphrenia, God, quantum physics, which is probably overly ambitious on my part. You have given me some ideas that I should discuss the impact on Chris's brothers, but they seem to understand the situation and are supportive. On the other hand, they are urging Chris to do something with his life now that he seems to be more resilient. Chris is doing very well, is 27 years old, sings Handel and Haydn solos in church and is involved in the local amateur operatic society. He also spends two days a week out of town working for an artist. We are all waiting for him to one day announce to us that is is ready to leave the nest and here is what he plans to do that involves further training or university. So far, that has not happened. The point of all those therapies that I dragged us through was to make him (and me!) more reslient, so that life's inevitable slings and arrows don't cripple him as they once did. He is definitely a new person. He has grown a new skin and is not the ghost person that he was as an infant and child. He actually has opinions now about things. I actually don't think that being the centre of attention is something that the person is deliberately demanding. It's more that psychosis is so shocking, so out of the ordinary, that everything else stops around it. But, you may be referring to the chapter on acting, and there is some truth to that. It is interesting that Chris is a soloist, because this means he has to be the center of attention, and he is finding that he is enjoying this. Performing was the last thing I ever imagined him doing when he was a child, since he was trying to fade away into the background. This is a long way of saying that schizophrenia, properly handled, is an opportunity to grow. Again, many thanks for your support and your comments!
...Rossa

Heavensent wrote 338 days ago

Hi Rossa
I finshed reading all the pages you have uploaded, it was quite an investment of time. Well spent I might add. The book gives lots of information on alternative therapies, medications etc. I was left wondering about the two other chilren and how they felt about Chris demanding so much of your time and energy? Do you cover this later in the book? I also wondered if a need to be the centre of attention is synonymous with schizophrenia? Of course the last and most important question is, how is Chris now, or do I have to wait for the book to be published to find out? I've shelved your book and starring it too. Thank you for sharing it.

Rossa Forbes wrote 343 days ago

Thank you, Heavensent. If you have further comments or questions, I'd be happy to respond.
All the best,
Rossa

Heavensent wrote 343 days ago

Dear Rossa

How wonderful that you have been able to document this journey. This book will be a source of of help and inspiration to so many people. I have read some of the pages today and hope to be back later to continue reading your story.

Very best wishes
HS

Dr Ajay Kansal wrote 349 days ago

Hi Rossa
This is an exceptionally important work. Thank you for sharing your experiences with schizophrenia and the medical remedies vs. the faith healing.
This is valuable for those who never encountered schizophrenia: they could understand what the suffering is. The rest who have encountered schizophrenia may learn how to wrestle with such a challenge. In context of your son, I salute your efforts. Being a doctor I am aware that parents of the patient suffer more than the patient.
Furthermore, schizophrenia is still the darkest field of modern medicine.
I wish your book get published: I will certainly buy one.
With best wishes.
Ajay

Dr Ajay Kansal wrote 349 days ago

Hi Rossa
This is an exceptionally important work. Thank you for sharing your experiences with schizophrenia and the medical remedies vs. the faith healing.
This is valuable for those who never encountered schizophrenia: they could understand what the suffering is. The rest who have encountered schizophrenia may learn how to wrestle with such a challenge. In context of your son, I salute your efforts. Being a doctor I am aware that parents of the patient suffer more than the patient.
Furthermore, schizophrenia is still the darkest field of modern medicine.
I wish your book get published: I will certainly buy one.
With best wishes.
Ajay

Rossa Forbes wrote 367 days ago

Thank you, Moe for your support. The difference between me and the other mother's who have written so far about schizophrenia, is largely in the attitude to medication and their belief that schizophrenia is a brain disease. Once you remove yourself from a medical attachment to the illness, I find that real healing is possible.

Have only read two chapters so far and intend to continue. I'm interested in the theme of hindsight-insight that is displayed, where meaning comes to you at a later point in time. That has a significance for me, one that I can relate too. Congratulations for making this journey, it feels very relevant now that we look at people as unique human beings rather than pigeon hole them and make them fit into what is easiest for the medical profession.

moesmith wrote 367 days ago

Have only read two chapters so far and intend to continue. I'm interested in the theme of hindsight-insight that is displayed, where meaning comes to you at a later point in time. That has a significance for me, one that I can relate too. Congratulations for making this journey, it feels very relevant now that we look at people as unique human beings rather than pigeon hole them and make them fit into what is easiest for the medical profession.

Rossa Forbes wrote 373 days ago

Dear Roberta,
Thank you very much for your comments, your backing and your rating. I am humbled. I hope my book informs people about the over-reliance on medications and pharma when it comes to mental health.
Best regards,
Rossa
Holistic Recovery from Schizophrenia: A Mother and Son Journey

Wow, this is a break-through book and excerpts should be published in The New Yorker or some such magazine. I also think this is a must read, possibly even for academia. First of all, it is extremely well written and exposes the miss-application of psychotropic drugs for mental health issues, which is especially rampant in the USA. As someone whom has worked with the homeless community I can attest to the unreliable efficacy of some of the medications. Medication is only effective with other treatment like behavioral modification (coping), environmental adaptation, and monitoring. As someone who knew there was something wrong with my son by age 3 (ADHD, ODD) I can attest to the tendency for institutional thinking and applying blame. I am definitely backing this book and rating a 6. Thanks for sharing your journey to the benefit of us all.
Roberta

healthpolicymaven wrote 374 days ago

Wow, this is a break-through book and excerpts should be published in The New Yorker or some such magazine. I also think this is a must read, possibly even for academia. First of all, it is extremely well written and exposes the miss-application of psychotropic drugs for mental health issues, which is especially rampant in the USA. As someone whom has worked with the homeless community I can attest to the unreliable efficacy of some of the medications. Medication is only effective with other treatment like behavioral modification (coping), environmental adaptation, and monitoring. As someone who knew there was something wrong with my son by age 3 (ADHD, ODD) I can attest to the tendency for institutional thinking and applying blame. I am definitely backing this book and rating a 6. Thanks for sharing your journey to the benefit of us all.
Roberta

Marita A. Hansen wrote 393 days ago

I read chapter 1 today, and thought it was very interesting, the little signs that you were picking up about the things that you felt weren't quite right about Chris's behaviour. The tapping of his head, the grandiose attitude, and his stand-offish attitude towards people. I haven't watched that film you mentioned, and didn't realise Nash was schizophrenic. I knew he had mental health issues, but it was interesting to hear about Nash's room-mate being in his imagination. But to a schizophrenic person, whether they are imaginary or not, they are very real to them.

I only noticed one thing that jumped out at me. You have a typo in regards to how late you were with Chris's pregnancy. It says you were 26 days overdue.

That's all for now. I'll have a read of chapter 2 when I get some more time. Off to write. Best wishes, Marita.

Rossa Forbes wrote 403 days ago


Marita - Thank you for your comments. I noticed your book on the top 5 list, but have not had much time to read other authors books of late. So I'm intrigrued to see that the hood is actually a neighbourhood and not a car hood, as I originally surmised. If it is easier, I can send you any chapters you want. I find it frustrating to read books on authonomy. There is only so much staring at a computer screen one can take.
Congratulations of your medal!
...Rossa

I saw your book recommended on the forum, and decided to read it because I've written about a schizophrenic character in my book. The person in chapter 2 and 4 is based on someone that I know, someone that is very important and dear. I'm not reading your book to get anything out of you as I have already got a medal on my book so you don't need to reciprocate. This review is purely because your topic is of interest.

I've just finished the introduction but will definitely be reading on. The mention of weight gain was something that jumped out at me. The person who has schizophrenia, as well as someone else I know who is classed as "Psychotic" (a horrible term), also complained about pills causing weight gain. I don't quite know everything about what the psychotic person experiences, but your mention of visions and voices fitted in with the schizophrenic person (I'd rather not name names). She has spirit guides, people who only she sees and speaks to.

Anyway, your intro was nicely written and I didn't notice anything that I could suggest to change. I'll let you know what I think of the first chapter when I get some more time. Kind regards, Marita.

Rossa Forbes wrote 403 days ago

Hi, Ben,
Thank you for taking the time to read a bit of my book and to send your comments. (Thanks for backing it!) No, I'm not an academic, just a mother who got pushed into something that she never imagined would happen. Interesting comment about the repetition. I am self-conscious about it, not sure if it works or not, so thanks for your feedback. I felt that my added value in writing the book was that I was a mother and most mothers are reluctant to write about their child's so called mental illness. I am also a mother who doesn't buy into the current love affair with pharma. I feel pharma lets parents off the hook of doing the really hard job of understanding and empathy, which leads to healing. Enough about me. I checked you out and see that your wine book will be published soon. Congratulationsl You also have a nice blog musing about the things that make live worth living - food, wine, music. You sound like the kind of person who I would love to have live next door.
Best regards,
Rossa


I have read the introduction and chapter 17. You write extremely well. The introduction is scholarly,

and makes me wonder whether you are an academic. Chapter 17, of course, moves into the memoir - because that is what this book is about. You use repetition effectively (rather than clunkily - a difficult trick to pull off). Even though I have only read two chapters, the book as a whole looks like it will be a convincing argument against the pharma industry and for alternative methods of healing. I am slightly dubious about amazing claims made (not in your book - just in general) on behalf of Alternative Medicine, having read 'Bad Science' by Ben Goldacre, but I suspect that for mental health issues the alternative model is valid in many cases.

Marita A. Hansen wrote 403 days ago

I saw your book recommended on the forum, and decided to read it because I've written about a schizophrenic character in my book. The person in chapter 2 and 4 is based on someone that I know, someone that is very important and dear. I'm not reading your book to get anything out of you as I have already got a medal on my book so you don't need to reciprocate. This review is purely because your topic is of interest.

I've just finished the introduction but will definitely be reading on. The mention of weight gain was something that jumped out at me. The person who has schizophrenia, as well as someone else I know who is classed as "Psychotic" (a horrible term), also complained about pills causing weight gain. I don't quite know everything about what the psychotic person experiences, but your mention of visions and voices fitted in with the schizophrenic person (I'd rather not name names). She has spirit guides, people who only she sees and speaks to.

Anyway, your intro was nicely written and I didn't notice anything that I could suggest to change. I'll let you know what I think of the first chapter when I get some more time. Kind regards, Marita.

Ben Hardy wrote 403 days ago

I have read the introduction and chapter 17. You write extremely well. The introduction is scholarly, and makes me wonder whether you are an academic. Chapter 17, of course, moves into the memoir - because that is what this book is about. You use repetition effectively (rather than clunkily - a difficult trick to pull off). Even though I have only read two chapters, the book as a whole looks like it will be a convincing argument against the pharma industry and for alternative methods of healing. I am slightly dubious about amazing claims made (not in your book - just in general) on behalf of Alternative Medicine, having read 'Bad Science' by Ben Goldacre, but I suspect that for mental health issues the alternative model is valid in many cases.

Rossa Forbes wrote 436 days ago

Thank you, Judy, for these really nice words. I've looked at your book, it looks promising, and will put it on my WL for the time being for a better read later. I'm not as active on this site right now as I would hope.
Best regards,
Rossa

J.Adams wrote 437 days ago

It has already been said - this is an important work. Thank you for sharing your and Chris's experiences with schizophrenia and the accepted medical practice vs. the myriad alternatives one can explore. I wish you both well, I hope you will let me know if or when you post the rest of your book, and I hope you find a publisher. Books like this are too important to fall by the wayside. This needs to be out where people who seek alternatives can find it and benefit from your insights.
All the best,
Judy

Rossa Forbes wrote 442 days ago

Balepy - Much appreciated.
Rossa (Holistic Recovery from Schizophrenia: A Mother and Son Journey)

Balepy wrote 442 days ago

Rossa - your book on schizophrenia and various methods of seeking recovery is invaluable. Backed with stars and I shall read more of it. Balepy (Freckles the Fawn)

Balepy wrote 442 days ago

Rossa - your book on schizophrenia and various methods of seeking recovery is invaluable. Backed with stars and I shall read more of it. Balepy (Freckles the Fawn)

Rossa Forbes wrote 447 days ago

That's very interesting aboubt Kraepelin and the Rockefeller Foundation. I did a quick google check and his Institute in Munich received the Rockefeller money two years after Kraepelin died. If you have further information on why Rockefeller was interested in psychiatric research, I'd appreciate hearing about it.

Thanks for supporting my book. I revised my profile about an hour ago to reflect what I think is really unique about my memoir.

Cristy DeLange wrote 447 days ago

Excactely that's misspelled but who cares. Prozac and other drugs is an invention of the parmaceutical companies to fill their pockets. It also keeps the psychiatrists aflood, who otherwise will be out of work and in the ditch. I learned during my research that Kraeplin received $ 575,000 for research in Europe from Rockefeller. They owned the petroleum industry and they recently had discovered that by poducts of petroleum could be used to produce medicine.

M. A. McRae. wrote 449 days ago

This is a well-written and an absorbing book, but more importantly, it is a valuable book that points out the failures of pyschiatry - failures that ruin lives.
This is one that I would buy, and study. This is an exceptional book.
Marj.

Rossa Forbes wrote 451 days ago

What an interesting and well written book. I am sure it would be of great help to others close to someone with schizophrenia. I am finding it fascinating and have WL'd for backing as soon as possible. In the meantime, high starred.
Vall (Midwyf)



Vali - Thanks very much. I'll swing by your book on midwifery as soon as possible for a read.

Rossa Forbes wrote 451 days ago

Thanks, Liz. Your book looks promising and I will take a look at it when I come up for air. Will put it on my watch list to remind me that I promised you a read. I would appreciate any comments you have in your capacity as a psych nurse.

Best regards,
Rossa Forbes
Holistic Recovery from Schizophrenia

Vall wrote 451 days ago

What an interesting and well written book. I am sure it would be of great help to others close to someone with schizophrenia. I am finding it fascinating and have WL'd for backing as soon as possible. In the meantime, high starred.
Vall (Midwyf)

lizjrnm wrote 452 days ago

As a psych nurse I am enthralled with this so far. So very candid and certainly hopeful! Shelved with pleasure.

Liz
The Cheech Room

TheImpeccableEditor wrote 453 days ago

On my shelf!
i.e.
The Impeccable Editor's Guide to Writing (and Rewriting)

12